Boycotting the people of Scotland

The usual blog article begins after this message while the annual crowdfunder is running. Sorry for the intrusion. Your support for the Wee Ginger Dugfunder is immensely appreciated. All donations large and small are welcome, yet if you are unable to donate that too is fine. Everyone will continue to enjoy full and unfettered access to all the contents of this blog.

In the first 24 hours, £1808 had been donated via GoFundMe, £4747 via PayPal, and £254 via other methods, making a total of £6809. What a fantastic start!

There are a number of ways to donate. You can use the PayPal button on this page. you don’t need a Paypal account to use the donate button. If you don’t have a Paypal account, just select “donate with card” after clicking the button.
Donate Button

Alternatively you can make a PayPal payment directly to, or you can click the following link to GoFundMe where credit and debit card donations are accepted.

If you would prefer to donate by cheque or some other method, please email me at for details.

Many thanks in advance. Both me and the dug appreciate all the support and love.

The Tories and the Lib Dems have decided that they’re going to boycott the Citizens’ Assembly initiative of the Scottish Government which is being chaired by former Labour MEP David Martin. They have been joined in their refusal by those professional proponents of nawbaggery, Scotland in Union. This is because getting a representative sample of the Scottish population together in one room to discuss the future of Scotland is only going to allow people to talk about independence, and that will never do. The Tories only want to hear from the Scottish people when those Scottish people happen to be fully signed up members of the Tory party. Or failing that the local lodge. Though there’s considerable overlap there.

The Lib Dems aren’t wearing it because that representative sample of the Scottish populace might say that they want a referendum that’s not a Jo Swinson approved referendum. And we can’t have Jo being shown up as a liar now, can we.

The Tories’ Adam It’s The Law Tomkins dismissed the Citizens’ Assembly as a “nationalist stunt to kick-start the conversation about independence”. Imagine the audacity, people in Scotland discussing options for Scotland’s constitutional future which aren’t pre-approved by Adam. Meanwhile Wullie Rennie took a break from driving the number 17 to Kelty to tell people at the bus stop that the Assembly was an “SNP exercise set up to simply to patch up the SNP’s case for independence”. Which was grand, but the only statement anyone wanted from Wullie was some info on when the bus to Cowdenbeath was due.

The key thing here is that the members of the Citizens’ Assembly will be selected in such a way as to provide a representative sample of the Scottish population. They will therefore represent the real balance in Scottish opinion between independence and the UK, between remaining in the EU or Brexit, between women and men, between young and old, between Scottish born and Scottish by adoption. The members will be a representative sample of political party voting intention, or none. The members of the Citizens’ Assembly are not going to be hand picked by the Scottish Resistance. Nicola Sturgeon isn’t going to go through a list of names and pre-approve only those who have a YES poster in their windae. It is difficult to comprehend why any reasonable person should have an issue with this. But then the clue is in the phrase “reasonable person”.

The point of the exercise is to try and find some sort of consensus in Scotland about the way ahead. The Tories and the Lib Dems are forever telling us how divisive the independence debate is. You’d think that they would welcome an initiative which aims to bring people together and allow them to discuss Scotland’s constitutional differences in a calm and reasonable manner with the goal of finding some common ground. That’s the real way to heal divisions. But for all that the Tories go on about how dreadful divisions in society are, the truth is that they don’t want to do anything to heal those divisions. The Tories just want absolute victory. The only healing of divisions that the Conservatives can countenance is the absolute crushing of the independence cause. Dialogue threatens them. The Conservatives can only comprehend control and domination.

Now in their intransigence they’ve just handed the independence movement another weapon to use against them. The next time anyone in the Tory party bewails the divisions in Scotland we only need to point out that the Tories have rejected the only serious proposal made to find common ground and to heal those divisions. The truth is that the Tories depend upon the divisions, because they need something that they can present as a threat in order to scare people into supporting them. It’s not like they’ve got anything positive to offer Scotland. Without constantly harping on about how they don’t want a referendum, the Tories in Scotland would have nothing to say. They need that wedge, they need the divisions they create by banging on about it to the exclusion of all other policies. It’s all they’ve got.

If the Tories and their pals are boycotting this initiative, is can only be because irrespective of their excuses they don’t want to hear what the people of Scotland really think. It can only be because they want to set limits on what the people of Scotland can or cannot decide to be in the best interests of Scotland. That’s not listening, that’s dictating. Or it could be that the Tories and the Lib Dems are struggling to grasp the concept of ‘representative’. This is possibly the kindest explanation, and certainly allows us to understand why they think that they can tell everyone in Scotland what to do even though they are minority parties.

But what this boycott really show us is the vacuum at the heart of Scottish opposition to independence. Participation in the Citizens’ Assembly would only expose how the Conservatives have undermined devolution, how they’ve ignored the will of the Scottish people in pursuit of a Brexit that Scotland doesn’t want, how they plan to centralise the UK even further. You can’t participate in a forum that allows citizens to speak when your entire politics depends upon silencing the citizenry. All you can do is to try to delegitimise the forum.

Participating in the Citizens’ Assembly would mean that the Tories, the Lib Dems, and the SiU would have to reach beyond their naaaaawwwww! comfort zone. They’d have to develop a positive case for the Union. They’d have to offer something concrete. They’d have to spell out their plans for strengthening devolution and the Scottish parliament, and for ensuring that Scotland has a strong voice and real influence within this so-called precious union that is no real union at all. They’d have to demonstrate how Scotland can grow and flourish and achieve as a part of the UK in a way that it couldn’t do as an independent country. But they can’t do that.

The Tories say that they don’t want to participate in the Citizens’ Assembly because they don’t want to legitimise talk of independence. What they really mean is that they don’t want to legitimise the right of the people of Scotland to decide for themselves what sort of future this country needs. They can’t do that because being a British nationalist in Scotland means to surrender control of Scotland’s destiny to Westminster.

What sort of vision is it when all that you can offer the people of Scotland as a prospectus for the future boils down to, “We have to let someone else decide for us and speak for us.” All the more so when that someone else is Boris Johnson or Jeremy Hunt, that decision is Brexit, and what they say is that Scotland must wheesht and do as it is told. You can’t offer a vision when all your party offers Scotland is to go into the future wearing a union flag blindfold.

The Tories aren’t just boycotting the Citizens’ Assembly, they’re boycotting the people of Scotland. The real reason why the Tories and their allies are boycotting the Citizens’ Assembly is the same as the reason why they are so desperate to prevent another independence referendum from happening. It’s because they have nothing to offer Scotland except being silenced and being submissive, and because they are terrified of the verdict of the people of Scotland on all of Westminster’s lies and deceit. But they can’t hide forever, and when the people of Scotland do give their verdict on their record, on the way that the UK has treated Scotland, it will be a damning one.

23 comments on “Boycotting the people of Scotland

  1. Bob Lamont says:

    Superb stuff, no great surprise reaction from the usual suspects, democracy is what they control.
    The principles of Citizen Assemblies will see SNP criticised heavily, no bad thing as that’s how they’re supposed to work, hopefully they have the guts to let it flow…
    No surprise the anti shower are against anything SNP promoted, after all, 5 yearly FPTP lies and expensive campaigns have served them so well, were it not for the electorate…

  2. Sandra Bolton says:

    I agree with everything you say. The only extra point I would make is the media..and where it stands n the issue of Independence. They too have a lot of influence over our affairs…imo..they should be impartial. Where they are not they should be called out. It’s too serious a situation not to.

  3. Brian Lucey says:

    When PM BoJoHunt or PM HuntBoJo denies a second independence referendum, what then? Whats plan B?
    My thruppence – all SNP MP’s resign, and pledge in the event of say 60% or more seats pledge to sit as a independent parliament. Worked for Ireland in ’19

    • Malcolm says:

      You are correct Brian. I suggested a few months ago that the Scottish Government should call an election with a mandate of Independence. That should start the ball rolling !!!

      • derek bell-jack says:

        the trouble with calling a general election in Scotland,with an independence mandate,is that we would miss all the 16-17 year old voters,and a lot of EU nationals living and working here.a referendum would be the best way forward,and Westminster knows this.

  4. […] Wee Ginger Dug Boycotting the people of Scotland The usual blog article begins after this message while the annual crowdfunder is […]

  5. Archie says:

    They’re doing the same as they did in 2014. By not taking part, they prevent the debate happening. Then they can claim there’s no debate, and make sure pro-independence arguments don’t get aired, because they know they won’t appear in regular media.

    • Welsh Sion says:

      … with the self-same media cheerleading for the likes of Rooth ‘that that essenpee is banging on about independence.’

      A vicious circle, indeed.

      That’s why it’s imperative the real message must keep on getting out there to your fellow-citizens, Scotland. And *you* do the boycotting of the yoons and their MSM sympathisers.

  6. Robert Graham says:

    Agreed totally Paul ,

    A whole series of posters for billboards you have assembled

    Just taking a minute to look out the Stars n Stripes I know I had it somewhere,

    Looking forward to seeing the English wave their flag and sing their Anthem

    watching the game with the sound down because a little weary of 1966 again .

    And they wonder why most Scots support the opposition even in bloody tiddlywinks.

  7. Robert Graham says:

    Bloody BBC they must have twigged about the sound bit and are filling the screen with bloody messages from long gone has beens , Bas***s .

  8. Alisdair says:

    Thank you Sir for that final paragraph, it is the best example of the pen being mightier than the sword that I have ever read.

    • Robert Graham says:

      Ha Ha Excellent- Welsh Sion , Gubbed by another upstart who told them to stick their Union up their A***s .

  9. Robert Graham says:

    Oh Dear Engerlund oot ,
    how sad never mind ,
    you all know that’s the last you will see of the fitba ,
    A re-run of dads army will be taking the place of the next two games .
    They wouldn’t do that now would they ? .

  10. Millsy says:

    Democracy is obviously either a dirty word in the Tory/Libdem households , or is seriously misunderstood .
    Judging from the usual statements from (t)Ruth Davidson , Fluffy Mundell and Jo Swinson it must be the latter .

  11. John McLeod says:

    There is another dimension to the Tory, LibDem, SIU advice to people to refuse to participate in Citizen Assemblies. This dimension concerns a lack of respect for the capacity of citizens to make up their own minds. If Tories (etc) take part in assemblies and come out and say they have given it a chance, but feel they have been manipulated – then this is evidence that the assembly process is not working as it should. The current position of Tories (etc) is that those who support them are not capable of arguing their own case or arriving at their own judgements.

  12. Craig P says:

    The union is fecked. The discussion we need to have is, how do we maintain good relations with England after Brexit and its aftermath? And how do we give counselling and show compassion to Scotland’s shell-shocked British nationalists after the English have rejected them and told them there is no Britain, they can support England or piss off?

  13. wm says:

    A Citizen Assembly is about bringing people of all parties together for grown up discussions and debates. This does not suit the Tories of this country as they have been using every method in the book to devide people for centuries, and they come in the yellow as well as the blue version.

    • Bob Lamont says:

      Having citizens in charge of anything is fundamentally dangerous to ALL modern politicians, I hope SNP et al follow it through on the Irish principles and accept it as intended.
      Swinson of course will reinterpret it all bass-ackward in wandering accents whatever the subject or outcome, but the Tories will fight it tooth and nail to to divide and conquer but to maintain absolute control…
      To illustrate how far this nasty cartel are prepared to go, it’s well worth reading George Monbiot’s piece in the Grauniad. Despite centring on a Labour Party commissioned report on land reform for further discussion, the media war unleashed by Tory connected media attack dogs was brutal, no second guess how Citizens Assembly outcomes would be treated…

  14. Terry callachan says:

    To Craig P…good point you make.

  15. alasdair smith says:

    Brilliant article as always. Theresa May plans to review devolution but the Scottish tories refuse to discuss constitutional future in Scotland. Surely even the tories can see a clash of strategies North and South of the border. How can the Scottish Tories not take part in a citizens assembly but be quite happy to participate in a review of devolution? not very consistent.

    • Melvin says:

      It’s quite simple they are right we are wrong. We are stupid upstarts who don’t understand who are masters are.we should be grateful that we get any money back from our taxes/ extortion we pay to Westminster. Don’t worry Ruth will be along to explain it again, with their lib dem and labour poodles in tow.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s