Crass Weirdness en de beste vrienden van Davie in Europa

Some things in life are entirely predictable – like the universal stretching of the fabric of space time which is slowly pulling apart all matter and which one day, billions of years in the future, will leave only formless disjointed particles of nothingness lost in the cold dark vastness of the cosmos; and then there’s BBC Scotland which manages the same job in about half an hour. There a wee sciencey joke for you Ken son, hope it cheers you up, because you must be sick about what your bosses have done with your programme.

I tuned into BBC Scotland’s new Crossfire programme, the replacement for the popular Headlines programe. This is the programme that Kezia Dugdale became unavailable for at the last minute, because she’s been too busy recently complaining to the Daily Mail about people being nasty to her. The Daily Mail know a lot about being nasty to people, and so does Kezia so it’s a match made in heaving – and quite a bit of retching too.

Or at least I tuned into Crossfire for about five minutes, which was more than enough. You’re not going to get a proper review because listening to the show’s heid pounding shoutiness was like suffering all the symptoms of a hangover, which is not really something you plan to experience on a Sunday morning unless you got rat arsed the night before. And if you were rat arsed the night before, you’re not going to be getting up on a Sunday morning to have your heid nipped – unless it’s by your significant other. If I had wanted to spend my Sunday in the company of shouty people yelling at one another, I’d have gone and visited my sister and her teenage offspring.

The programme seemed to consist of swapping sound bites from press releases and very little else. There was precious little in the way of insight or informed commentary. For most of the few minutes I was listening some woman, whose name I didn’t catch and don’t want to catch in order to spare her embarrassment, was following in the footsteps of Magrit Curran and talking a lot of mince over the top of everyone else. Though it’s probably viciously sexist to point that out. The only thing anyone has learned from Bit Whore Tag Udder in this referendum campaign is that it’s bullying and abuse to criticise pro-Union misinformation when it comes from women, carers, mothers, lesbians, gay men, straight men, ethnic minorities, disabled people, elderly people, English people, authors of fantasy fiction, warmongers, Westminster politicians, members of the Labour shadow cabinet, Slovenians with a persecution complex and OCD, Labour MSPs and cooncillors, members of the House of Lords, lizard space aliens, garden gnomes, and stuffed toys – that would be David Mundell.

Feeling caught in the destructive and non-illuminating crossfire of political dogwhistles, I tuned out and turned on the kettle instead. It made a reassuring whistle when it boiled and I had a nice cup of tea, unlike the Crossfire programme, which just boiled and steamed away and made a mess all over the floor of the BBC studio. The used teabag ended up in the bin, which is where Crossfire’s stewed bag of vegetable matter with the taste leeched out is likely to end up very shortly too.

You’ve got to wonder about BBC Scotland management. Is it possible to be this incompetent by accident? Or are they doing it on purpose? It is a possibility that BBC managers are playing their part in a devilish strategy to produce such crap programmes that no one will engage with the referendum debate, but that assumes a level of guile, intelligence and cunning which there’s no evidence that they possess. But it does take a very special kind of moronic incompetence to produce a radio progamme that would actually have been more listenable if it had had Kezia Dugdale in it.

Please send your questions about BBC Scotland’s descent into irrelevance on a postcard to Ken MacQuarrie. You won’t get an answer, but Ken’s looking to add to his collection of smutty seaside innuendo. It started after a BBC staff member archly asked him if he was going to continue with the cock ups, and Ken thought it was a recommendation to look at dirty postcards.

Meanwhile in news you may have missed because the BBC’s Crass Weirdness has left you bleeding from the ears, the Sunday Herald reports that Davie Cameron’s Tories, lost and friendless in the European Parliament, have now formed a new grouping of MEPs together with the Flemish centre right N-VA party. Mainly because no one in Europe wants to be seen dead with the Tories either.

It’s possibly cruel to point out – and naturally that means I’ll be pointing out with glee – that the Tories’ new pals in Europe support the independence of Flanders from Belgium. They’re also pretty keen on Scottish independence too. In order to have any significant influence in the European Parliament, Davie’s boys and girls now find themselves reliant upon the support of a party who cheer for Alicsammin. That’s gotta hurt.

In April this year, the party’s online magazine carried an article by one of its leading MEPs, Mark Demesmaeker who sits on the European Parliament’s external relations committee. The article extolled the Scottish Yes campaign and praised Alicsammin’s speech in Bruges. It’s all in Dutch, but the article is titled YES SCOTLAND! in English, which kinda gives you a clue as to the sentiments expressed within it.

The article goes on to explain that in the view of this N-Va politician, there should be no difficulty with an independent Scotland rapidly acceding to full EU membership in its own right, and agrees with the assessment that Scotland will be able to negotiate its membership in the period between a yes vote in September, and the formal declaration of independence some 18 months later.

The Tories were hoping that Yes supporters in Scotland hate foreigners as much as they do and won’t pollute their eyes with texts which are not in English. But the Nederlands-challenged can get the gist of the piece courtesy of Google Translate – which is apparently the same service the Scotsman newspaper used to mistranslate Pope Francis’s comments on independence for Catalonia and Scotland.

The N-VA’s online magazine also carried a recent piece by Dr Dirk Rochtus, a professor of politics and social sciences at Leuven University and a senior fellow of the Centre for European Integration based in Bonn in Germany. Dr Rochtus has a long and respected list of publications in the field of independence movements and international politics.

Dr Rochtus wrote an article looking at the issues facing an independent Scotland which seeks membership of the EU. The Dutch language article, entitled Een onafhankelijk Schotland: automatisch EU-lid of niet? (An independent Scotland: Automatic EU entry or not?) was published in the N-VA party magazine in January this year.

Dr Rochtus recognises that there are questions about Scottish membership, but notes that the objections raised by No campaigners in Scotland – he cites Alistair Carmichael – are politically motivated and politically based. The professor notes that they have no basis in EU law. He goes on to make a number of interesting points. Scottish membership of the EU may not be automatic – but Scottish expulsion from the EU is not automatic either, contrary to the opinions proferred by the likes of the Alistairs. In fact, the expulsion of Scotland from the EU throws up far more complex and thorny legal issues than Scotland’s automatic accession to full membership. So it’s not going to happen.

It’s a safe bet that the opinion of a professor who specialises in the study of independence movements and who is a senior fellow with the Centre for European Integration is probably somewhat weightier than that of a solicitor in Kirkwall. Dr Rochtus appears to be of the view that any issues in the way of an independent Scotland gaining EU membership are solvable and can be surmounted. Here’s a link to a (mangled) Google Translate English language version of the article. (Sorry, but my Dutch is nowhere near good enough to translate it myself.)

So we have the Tories to thank for this new support for Scottish membership of the EU. If they hadn’t formed an alliance in the European Parliament with the N-VA, it’s likely that no one on the Yes side of the Scottish independence debate would have gone looking for the opinions of the Tories’ new best pals in Europe.

But now we know. In order to secure his much wanted renegotiation of the UK’s terms of membership of the EU, Davie Cameron must rely upon the support of a party that’s strongly in favour of a smooth entry into the EU for an independent Scotland. That’s an even bigger screw up for the No campaign than the launch of yet another PR disaster for BBC Scotland.

 

 

Advertisements

19 comments on “Crass Weirdness en de beste vrienden van Davie in Europa

  1. mary vasey says:

    God bless you Paul, just been over on wings checking out latest article and came away decidedly blue, so was in sair need of cheering up. As usual your article has fair hit the spot. Still laughing at David Mundell jeez what a cracker. Thanks once more for cheering me up as well as enlightening me 😎

  2. Hugh Wallace says:

    Reblogged this on Are We Really Better Together? and commented:
    “So we have the Tories to thank for this new support for Scottish membership of the EU. If they hadn’t formed an alliance in the European Parliament with the N-VA, it’s likely that no one on the Yes side of the Scottish independence debate would have gone looking for the opinions of the Tories’ new best pals in Europe.

    But now we know. In order to secure his much wanted renegotiation of the UK’s terms of membership of the EU, Davie Cameron must rely upon the support of a party that’s strongly in favour of a smooth entry into the EU for an independent Scotland. That’s an even bigger screw up for the No campaign than the launch of yet another PR disaster for BBC Scotland.”

  3. You mean the Tories have joined with a group they haven’t bombarded with No material! Perhaps we can hope this group works to force some enlightenment into Tory thinking.

  4. macart763 says:

    “But it does take a very special kind of moronic incompetence to produce a radio progamme that would actually have been more listenable if it had had Kezia Dugdale in it.”

    Wash yer keyboard out with bleach. 😀

    That’s the second wee EU bombshell in the past few days. You’ll have seen this wee beezer over on Wings?

    http://wingsoverscotland.com/sunset-for-scaremongers/

    More and more the current EU narrative from BTVNOBNTUKOK looks to have been blown out of the water quite comprehensively. Along with Danny getting his erse handed to him by Mr Dunleavy and both the treasury and civil service left looking like prats, it hasn’t been a productive weekend for the no campaign.

    http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/jun/22/independent-scotland-startup-costs-200million

    I reckon that’s why they’re concentrating their fire on currency and the dreaded cybernat smear. I suspect they know the gemme’s a bogey on the EU front. 😉

  5. yerkitbreeks says:

    Totally agree about “Crossfire” – completely bland and in the 10 minutes I listened it provided nothing vaguely new.

  6. […] Some things in life are entirely predictable – like the universal stretching of the fabric of space time which is slowly pulling apart all matter and which one day, billions of years in the future,…  […]

  7. Jaffa McNeill says:

    Wouldn’t get too pally with Flanders seperatists my ginger pal, they can be slightly on the facist side of fruitus batus.

    • weegingerdug says:

      Oh I’m not remotely pally with politicians of a right wing persuasion. They’re the UK Tories’ pals. I’m just pointing out the Euro difficulties that Davie Cameron has got himself into. And doing that Spanish regodeo thang.

  8. Eilean says:

    I`m going to the BBC demo on Sunday 29th I think it is at 2pm.(don’t quote me) I am informed that my local Yes group are putting on a bus to Pacific Quay. I hope we get a decent turnout. I think that people are getting increasingly angry at the BBC. I think that it is scandalous the way they are carrying on. You couldnae gie them a red neck wi a blowlamp. Neither you could!

    I am waiting for some badges that I ordered to arrive this week. “Better Together – No Thanks” and “BBC Bias-No Thanks” They are rare and precious things as I only ordered five of each. Paul two of the badges are reserved for your good self.

    • gerry parker says:

      I hope to be there with the Wings banner Ian, laid up with a sore foot at the moment.

      • Jim McNeill says:

        ln a way you’ve got to admire the dedication of the BBC employees gambling their jobs on a No vote. Because they’ll sure as hell be unemployable in an independent Scotland.

        Sent from Samsung Mobile

      • Eilean says:

        I`l gie you a cary-code. 🙂

        • Eilean says:

          Sorry the above was for Gerry.

          Lets get right intae them! I will give a “BBC Bias-No Thanks” badge to the loudest campaigner on the day!

  9. JimnArlene says:

    Once again, brilliant.

  10. Sheltie2014 says:

    I don’t think my husband is going to mind me saying this but I think I love you, lol.
    I find you funny, informative and a breath of fresh air.
    Crack on

  11. Capella says:

    I listened to the whole Crossfire programme – how public spirited of me! You are right about the motor mouthed woman (I can’t remember her name either, it was double barreled). This is not a sexist observation as Anas Sarwar was just as verbally incontinent in the debate with Nicola Sturgeon. I think it may be a Labour training technique in how to conduct public debate.
    As usual, the telephone link to the YES spokesman was broken. What an amusing trick.
    I won’t listen again unless to confirm it really is as dire as my first impression. Listen to Bateman radio instead!

  12. arthur thomson says:

    Humour, insight AND poetry all in one day. Thank you as always.

  13. david porter says:

    Tuned in halfway through “Crossfire,” honestly thought at first it was a very bad spoof with some wummin doing a good impression of Magrit Kurrn, instead it turned out to be just a very bad programme.
    How could BBC Scotland do this to the excellent Ken MacDonald? OK, I’m not that naive.

  14. Hi Paul, we must have listened to a different 5 minutes of’ “Cross legs” on Sunday morning. I got the bit where they spoke about how Susan Boyle is going to be doing pantomime this winter!

    That’s the type of political insightfulness we need, so well done to the BBC management.
    They didn’t say which character she was going to play, so I’m still a little confused how I’ll vote in September.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s